Smith Island Crab Cake ($5.99 Each) Tender Colossal Jumbo Lump Crab Meat. Ingredients are layered over the crab meat, seasoned and gently folded with a mild cream sauce to bind the meat. “Definitely Our Best – Prize Winner”
Contains: wheat, milk, soy, crab, egg
Rock Hall Crab Cake ($5.99 Each) Colossal jumbo lump meat, lightly seasoned, folded in a buttery cream sauce, egg washed and breaded.
Contains: wheat, milk, soy, crab
Signature Crab Cake ($5.79 Each) A very traditional Maryland Style Jumbo Lump Crab Cake. “Our Original” Egg, mayo, seasonings and bread crumbs.
Contains: wheat, soy, crab, egg
Premium Crab Cake ($5.49 Each) Jumbo Lump Crab Meat folded in a Turmeric Cream Mousse.
Contains: wheat, soy, crab egg (contains no peppers)
Imperial Crab Cake ($4.99 Each) All Jumbo Lump Crab Meat in a mild cream sauce egg washed and breaded.
Contains: wheat, milk, soy, crab, egg
The Captain’s Mega Colossal Crab Cake approx. 5.5 oz. ($11.99 ea) We start with Colossal Jumbo Lump Crab Meat, sweetened with Hellmann’s mayo, gently secretly spiced, dusted in unseasoned American bread crumbs, flashed browned to perfection. You might think you just ate a dozen crabs!!!
Contains: Crab, milk, egg, wheat, soy
Monster Stuffed Shrimp ($4.99 Each) Jumbo Lump Crab Meat folded in an Imperial Sauce and wrapped around a Monster Shrimp.
Contains: wheat, milk, soy, crab, egg
Shrimp Cake ($4.99 Each) Large chunks of Shrimp in our Parmesan cream sauce.
Contains: wheat, milk, soy, shrimp, egg
Lobster Cake ($5.99 Each) Lobster meat folded into our creamy imperial sauce. Pan sauté’ or broil and these are a true delight.
Contains: wheat, milk, soy, lobster, egg
Cod Fish Cakes ($4.99 Each) Handmade, classic Cod Fish Cakes just like you remember! Packed full with big chunks of delicious Cod.
Crab Imperial Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms ($7.99 Each) The Captain’s famous crab imperial stuffed into a fresh, jumbo Portobello mushroom. Ready to bake!
Coconut Shrimp ($7.99 Pk of 10) Shrimp hand breaded in a flavorful, coconut coating leaving a nice sweet & crunchy flavor. Served with a sweet chili Thai sauce that will leave you craving more!
Colossal Hand Breaded Shrimp ($9.99 Pk of 8) Extra large, hand breaded, wild caught shrimp coated with a flavorful seasoned breadcrumb. Deep fried and ready to eat. 15 minutes in the oven and you have a true delight.
Colossal Hand Breaded Scallops ($9.99 Pk of 8) Our wild caught, colossal scallop, hand breaded and flash fried. Ready to bake. 15 minutes in the oven and you are in scallop heaven!
Colossal “Select” Hand Breaded Oysters ($8.99 Pk of 6) These are for the true oyster fans. These are not for the rookies! Jumbo, hand breaded oysters, flash fried and ready to heat. Yum!
Breaded Oysters ($7.99 Per dozen) Chesapeake style, fresh shucked oysters coated with a flavorful seasoned breadcrumb. Deep fried and ready to eat. 15 minutes at 400 degrees and you have a true delight!
Lobster Pot Pie ($7.99 Ea) A traditional pot pie filling with just the right amount of sherry and whole Maine lobster meat. Topped with a croissant pastry shell.Back to top
Beef – the “Turf” to compliment your “Surf”
We proudly offer Certified Angus Beef. Just as with our seafood, we will always offer the best quality product at the lowest possible price!
5 oz Filet Mignon Approx $5.99 Ea
8 oz Filet Mignon Approx $9.99 Ea
6 oz NY Strip Steak Approx $5.99 Ea
9 oz NY Strip Steak Approx $8.99 Ea
10 oz Ribeye Steak Approx $8.99 EaBack to top
We use only Jumbo Wild Caught Gulf of Mexico Shrimp. We clean and remove vein, steam it to an old fashioned snappy crunch
Steamed Shrimp (18 – $17.99)
Party Tray (10 people – 30 shrimp) $33.99 with cocktail sauce
Also available 40, 50 or 60 piece shrimp trays.
Party Tray (25 people – 75 shrimp) $73.99 with two cocktail saucesBack to top
Soups & Chowders
Cream of Crab Soup ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) Full of lump crab meat! Delicious over pasta such as bow tie or tortellini. Just add Parmesan cheese.
New England Clam Chowder ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) A cream soup full of clams! No potatoes ~ Delicious!
Snapper Soup ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) Snapping turtle soup at it’s finest! Chuck suggests adding a little sherry if you like.
Manhattan Clam Chowder ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) A traditional favorite tomato based soup made with vegetables and lots of tender clams.
Maryland Crab Soup ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) A tomato based soup made with vegetables and lots of crab meat!
Lobster Bisque ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) A brothy bisque made with Main Lobster meat.Back to top
Dips, Chips & Spreads
Crab Bowl ($15.99 Each) Great warm appetizer! Thick, cheesy crab dip in a hollowed out pub loaf. Serve with crackers and finish with the crispy Italian bread.
Crab Wasabi Spread ($5.99 Each ½ Pt) This cold cream cheese based spread has a wonderful crab and horseradish flavor with a touch of fresh cucumber and artichoke. Great with tortilla chips or crackers.
Cajun Lobster Spread ($6.99 Each ½ Pt) This cold cream cheese based spread has nice chunks of lobster with a little Cajun accent, but not over the top spicy. Great with tortilla chips or crackers.
Shrimp Scampi Dip ($5.99 Each ½ Pt) 1 minute in the microwave and you are in dip heaven! This warm cream cheese based dip is packed full with shrimp and all your traditional scampi ingredients including garlic, white wine and fresh shaved Parmesan cheese. Great with tortilla chips or crackers.
Clams Casino Dip ($5.99 Each ½ Pt) Can’t decide, but this one may be even better than the Shrimp Scampi Dip – you let us know! This warm cream cheese based dip is packed full with clams and all your traditional Casino ingredients including bacon, onions and peppers. We fold in a wonderful Gouda cheese to add a nice smoky flavor. Great with tortilla chips or crackers.
Mission Tortilla Chips ($3.99 Bag 13oz) If you’ve had a Mission chip- you know they are the BEST. An added bonus is that they are Gluten Free.Back to top
Crab Critter Appetizer ($15.99 Bag of 50) Bite sized, crab filled, breaded delights. Great for parties or a late night snack!
Crabalaya Cruncher Appetizer ($15.99 Bag of 20) Breaded, appetizer size portions of our popular Crabalaya stuffing.
Clamsters ($15.99 Bag of 20) Breaded, creamy blend of clams, cheese & spices. Ready to heat and serve.
Smith Island Crab Cake 1 oz Appetizer (Pre-order please)($1.99 ea) 1 oz portion of our AWARD winning crab cakes.
Imperial Crab Cake 1 1/2 oz Appetizer (Pre-order please)($1.59 ea) 1 ½ oz portion of our famous Imperial crab cakes.
Bacon Wrapped Scallops ($17.99 Pk of 16) Tender, wild caught scallops wrapped in bacon. Bake, broil or grill.
Crab Stuffed Deviled Eggs ($6.99 for 6pk, $29.99 for 30 pc tray) Wow- what a treat. Traditional style deviled eggs blended with blue crab, snow crab, horseradish and old bay seasoning. A real crowd pleaser.
Traditional Deviled Egg ($3.99 for 6pk, $16.99 for 30 pc tray) That’s right – you can now eat deviled eggs any night you choose without all the work. These are a nice traditional deviled egg to please anyone in the crowd.
Stuffed Clams ($7.99 Pk of 6) Jumbo clam shell filled with a perfectly seasoned clam stuffing. Loaded with fresh chopped clam!
Clams Casino ($9.99 Dozen) Little Neck Clams prepared with all the traditional Casino flavors. Great appetizer size or nice to satisfy that craving!
Breaded Calamari Fries ($5.99 1/2 lb Pk) Lightly breaded, wild caught. Ready to heat and serve! Great with the Captain’s cocktail sauce!
Colossal Breaded Clams ($5.99 1/2 lb Pk) Jumbo breaded clams like you’ve never seen before. Hand breaded, flash fried and ready for 10 minutes in the oven. These will put a smile on any clam lover’s face!
Hushpuppies ($4.99 Pk of 12) Good, old fashioned hushpuppies. Cornbread stuffing in a light breading. Coming straight up from North Carolina!
Crabalaya ($9.99 Pt) Incredible stuffing or dip! Crabmeat, sausage and New York Cheddar. Spread and bake in oven – great with tortilla chips or crackers.
Cocktail Crab Claws ($21.99 Can) Great for a get together or just as a snack. U30 size can averages about 30 blue crab claws per can.
Snow Crab Claws ($29.99 lb (Ave 21-25 lb)) Already cracked and ready to enjoy! These are great warmed up and dipped in butter or as a cold appetizer dipped in a traditional cocktail sauce. Mix them in a shrimp platter and you will have a real treat!
Spinach Stuffed Mushrooms ($1.49 Each) A blend of spinach, Monterrey jack, and our Imperial sauce. We use fresh cut silver dollar mushrooms. A vegetarian delight!Back to top
Homemade Seafood Pierogies
Shrimp Stuffed Pierogies ($14.99 Pk) These homemade pierogies are stuffed with shrimp and a cheesy mashed potato filling, staying true to a traditional Polish pierogi, but with an added twist of garlic, white wine and Parmesan. Sauté with some butter and onions. Mmmm!
Lobster Stuffed Pierogies ($16.99 Pk) These homemade pierogies are modeled after a Polish Farmer’s cheese pierogi. Packed full with chunks of lobster and other secret flavors. Sauté with some butter and onions. Mmmm!
Crab Stuffed Pierogies ($15.99 Pk) These homemade pierogies are stuffed with crab and a cheesy mashed potato filling, staying true to a traditional Polish pierogi. There is a three cheese blend that will keep you wanting more. Sauté with some butter and onions. Mmmm!
Smoked Salmon Stuffed Pierogies ($14.99 Pk) These homemade pierogies are the “Sleeper” of the bunch. Absolutely a “Must Try”. They are packed full of flavor with the smokiness of the Salmon, shallots and Gouda cheese folded into the traditional mashed potato base. Sauté with some butter and onions. Mmmm!
Variety Pack Seafood Stuffed Pierogies ($15.99 Pk) Not sure which one to try? Try them all…3 Shrimp, 3 Lobster, 3 Crab and 3 Smoked Salmon.
Potato & Cheese Stuffed Pierogies ($8.99 Pk) Not a fan of seafood – no worries! You can also enjoy a great homemade pierogi. These are stuffed with a perfect blend of mashed potato, American and Cheddar cheese. Best potato and cheese pierogi you will ever get from a seafood store. Sauté with some butter and onions. Mmmm!;Back to top
If it’s not listed below – we can get it in for you. Any fresh seafood you desire!
Deep Sea Scallops ($17.99 lb) Wild caught, jumbo scallops. These delicious, dry pack scallops will not shrink up when you cook them.
Jumbo Lump Crab Meat ($29.99 lb) Top of the line, jumbo lump meat! Great for a recipe or as a treat.
Alaskan King Crab Legs ($24.99 lb) The delicacy of all crab! The succulent flavor of king crab is like no other. Steam for a few minutes and enjoy the rich buttery flavor.
Snow Crab Legs ($12.99 lb) Sweet and succulent flavor of snow crab makes them one of the most popular. Steam for a few minutes and enjoy the snowy white meat.
1 lb Lobster Tail (Approx $29.99 Ea) The behemoth of tails! These jumbo tails are truly a treat. Sweet buttery flavor is a delight.
7 oz Lobster Tail (Approx $11.99 Ea) These tails are one of the most tender and flavorful lobster meats. Delicious treat at a great price!
4 oz Lobster Tail (Approx $6.99 Ea) These tails are one of the most tender and flavorful lobster meats. Perfect for a surf ‘n’ turf pairing!
Soft Shell Crabs ($4.99 Ea) These “Whales” are a wonderful delight. No matter what your preference – deep fried, sauteed or grilled, they are sure to please.
Norwegian Salmon ($4.99 5 oz Portion)Norwegian, Atlantic salmon 5 oz fillet. One of the best tasting salmon you will eat. Baked, broiled or grilled.
Mussels ($5.99 1 lb Pk) Unbelievably tender, precooked mussels. Simply thaw the pack and warm up in your favorite sauce.
Little Neck Clams ($5.99 1 lb Pk) Unbelievably tender, precooked clams. Simply thaw the pack and warm up in your favorite sauce.
Yellow Fin Tuna ($6.99 6 oz Portion) Wild caught, 6 oz tuna steak. Delicious broiled or grilled!
Pecan Encrusted Tilapia ($3.99 Each) Tilapia filet coated in a wonderful pecan bread crumb mixture, seasoned to perfection. Ready to slip in your oven!
Chili Lime Encrusted Tilapia ($3.99 Each) Tilapia filet coated in a fresh Cilantro lime blend.. Ready to slip in your oven!
Potato Encrusted Cod ($3.99 Each) Wild caught, Pacific Cod 5+oz filets with a savory Potato, cheddar and chive crust. A True Delight!
Breaded Flounder ($4.99 2 pc Pk) Wild caught, 4 oz breaded flounder filets. Simply bake and serve.
Flounder Filet ($4.99 2 pc Pk) Wild caught, 4 oz flounder fillets. Fantastic stuffed with the Captain’s crab imperial!
Mahi Mahi ($6.99 6 oz Portion) Wild caught, 6 oz Mahi Mahi portions. Great on the grill or in the oven!
We can get any type of seafood you could imagine, fresh or frozen. If you do not see it listed above, just give us a call. If we hear from your before 5PM on any weekday, we can have it in for you the next day.Back to top
Sides & Salads
Made Fresh Daily!
Cole Slaw ($2.99 1/2pt, $3.99 pt, $8.99 qt) Our “made from scratch” slaw leaves you with a sweet and crisp flavor in every bite!
Broccoli Salad ($2.99 1/2pt, $4.99 pt, $8.99 qt) Our crispy, fresh broccoli is folded into a sweet, creamy blend with a sprinkle of cranraisons and sunflower seeds.
Lobster Mac ‘n’ Cheese ($3.99 1/2pt, $6.99 pt, $12.99 qt) Need we say more? This traditional 3 cheese recipe has just a hint of sherry, whole Maine lobster meat and a seasoned breadcrumb topping.
Wild Caught Ahi Tuna Salad ($6.99 1/2pt, $12.99 pt, $24.99 qt) You know we wouldn’t just pop open a can! We fold our perfectly seasoned, wild caught Ahi tuna steaks into our delicious tuna salad dressing. Once you try this, you will never eat canned tuna again!
Buffalo Shrimp Mac ‘n’ Cheese ($3.99 1/2pt, $6.99 pt, $12.99 qt) What a fun treat! We take our wild caught shrimp and bake them into our mac ‘n’ cheese, drizzle our Buffalo sauce and coat with a seasoned breadcrumb topping.
Garlic Smashed Red Potatoes ($2.99 1/2pt, $4.99 pt, $8.99 qt) Hand smashed red potatoes blended with a perfect of garlic and seasonings.
Our Famous Grape Salad ($2.99 1/2pt, $4.99 pt, $8.99 qt) Best described as a grape wrapped in a piece of cheesecake. We take fresh grapes and fold them into a sweet and creamy mixture and top it off with a pecan, brown sugar blend.
Shrimp Salad ($6.99 1/2pt, $12.99 pt, $24.99 qt) Our colossal, wild caught shrimp, folded into a combination including, mayonnaise, white wine, Dijon and seasonings.Back to top
We proudly offer Talluto’s Authentic Italian Pasta to pair up with our sauces and compliment your seafood choices
Lobster Ravioli ($16.99 Dozen) Direct from Talluto’s 9th St Italian Market in Philadelphia! These hand made ravioli are fantastic when topped with the Captain’s Lobster Bisque.
Roasted Pepper & Goat Cheese Ravioli ($14.99 Dozen) Direct from Talluto’s 9th St Italian Market in Philadelphia! These handmade, tender ravioli are fantastic with the Captain’s Crab Marinara!
Mushroom Casencello ($7.99 per pk) Direct from Talluto’s 9th St Italian Market in Philadelphia! This light pasta stuffed with mushroom filling are great topped with our Marsala Wine sauce & shrimp!
Pesto Agnolotti ($9.99 per pk) Direct from Talluto’s 9th St Italian Market in Philadelphia! This light pasta stuffed with pesto filling are great topped with our creamy tomato vodka sauce & shrimp!Back to top
Sabi Sauce ($3.99 8oz Container) Our most popular dipping sauce! Creamy horseradish with just a hint of tomato. Great with our warm crab cakes, shrimp, critters or conch fritters!
Horseradish Sauce ($3.99 8oz Container) The Captain’s special blend of creamy horseradish with a little mustard, honey and Worcestershire sauce.
Cocktail Sauce ($3.99 8oz Container) A perfect blend of the traditional cocktail sauce ingredients with just enough zip!
Tarter Sauce ($3.99 8oz Container) A creamy blend of mayonnaise, sweet pickle and seasonings.
Crab Marinara ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) Capt’n Chucky’s crab marinara is made just like you grew up enjoying – BUT – without all the work! This perfectly seasoned sauce is packed full with blue crab meat. Try it over our Roasted Pepper & Goat cheese ravioli
Red Clam Sauce ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) Our wild caught ocean clams lightly sautéed in a zesty tomato sauce and seasoned to perfection. Great served over a bed of linguine!
White Clam Sauce ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt)Our wild caught ocean clams lightly sauteed in a creamy clam sauce and seasoned to perfection with just a touch of white wine. Great served over a bed of linguine!
Marsala Wine Sauce ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) We start by sauteing silver dollar mushrooms and flash them with a sweet Marsala wine. This smooth tasty sauce is delicious with shrimp or chicken over pasta!
Vodka Sauce ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt) This creamy tomato sauce is made from scratch and sure to please! Great over pasta with our wild caught shrimp!
Mild~Wild Shrimp Chili ($6.99 Pt or $12.99 Qt)Our famous shrimp chili! We take our delicious wild caught shrimp and slow cook them in a mild chili blend.Back to top
We proudly offer a full line of Pellman’s desserts to complete your meal
Key Lime Pie, Triple Chocolate Cake, Carrot Cake, Coconut Cake, Banana Cake, Pecan Pie, Cheesecake, Peanut Butter Pie, Apple Walnut Crumb CakeBack to top